3 Comments
User's avatar
Teresa Broderick's avatar

I'll be sticking with the originals in all cases! I think things are gone too far when you have to sanitise books. If you're easily offended then don't read them.

Expand full comment
Hildagarde Miller's avatar

I love her books. I have issues with anyone rewriting historical works.

Expand full comment
Carrie Etzel's avatar

This is really interesting. I agree that some of her really early works are problematic. I do wonder about preserving the attitudes of the time period. Consent in a historical context is tricky. When women had very few choices and marriage was frequently transactional, consent means something different.

I loved The Hathaways, but did wonder if modern Roma readers would feel comfortable with the representation.

Expand full comment